The Best True Crime Podcasts and YouTubers to Follow

If you’re anything like me, there’s nothing quite as intriguing as a good true crime story. The twists, the turns, the unanswered questions – it’s like a puzzle you can’t put down! Over the years, I’ve found myself deeply immersed in the world of true crime through podcasts and YouTube, where creators pour their hearts into unravelling the most mind-bending cases. Whether you’re a seasoned sleuth or brand new to the genre, I’ve got you covered with my favourite true crime creators. These channels and podcasts are where people like us (aka lovers of all things mysterious) find tales both chilling and fascinating.

From the curiosity-driven tones of podcasters to the emotionally captivating storytelling of YouTubers, here’s a roundup of the most binge-worthy creators who’ve turned true crime into their art form.

By the end of this article, you’ll have a list of incredible creators lined up for your next strange and sinister obsession. Buckle up; it’s about to get dark… in the best way possible.

Why True Crime Has Me Hooked

Ever find yourself staying up late, completely pulled in by a case that happened decades ago? That’s me, too. There’s something so enthralling about not just the cases but the insights into human behaviour, justice, and sometimes even societal flaws. True crime has this intense way of connecting us to real-world stories, showing us how much of life – and crime – straddles the line between bad luck, bad choices, and sometimes plain madness.

Podcasters bring you into the fold with their snug, conversational style, often feeling like a chat with an incredibly well-informed friend. YouTubers, on the other hand, create cinematic experiences that make you feel every twist and turn of the narrative. For me, watching or listening feels almost therapeutic, like piecing together the “why” behind the chaos of crime.

Now, onto the good stuff – the creators who breathe life into true crime content.

True Crime YouTubers Who Keep Me Glued

Whilst these are YouTubers, I listen to them often while working, driving or cooking and on the whole you do not need to actually be watching to enjoy listening.

Bailey Sarian

If you haven’t heard of Murder, Mystery & Makeup by Bailey Sarian, you’re missing out on one of the most iconic true crime YouTube experiences. Bailey has a unique way of blending her makeup artistry with captivating storytelling. Her light humour paired with her ability to narrate dark, unsettling cases is why she’s an absolute must-follow. Plus, who doesn’t love multitasking – makeup tips and murder?

Emma Kenny

Emma Kenny dives deep and asks the tough questions. A psychological therapist by trade, Emma offers expert-level breakdowns of cases. She doesn’t just scratch the surface – she analyses the mindset of criminals like no one else. Watching her feels like the perfect mix of true crime and a masterclass in psychology.

Stephanie Harlow

Stephanie is the queen of detail. Her videos explore every nook and cranny of a case, leaving no stone unturned. If you’re someone who loves going deep into the facts and finds joy in hearing “You probably haven’t heard this part of the case before,” Stephanie is your go-to true crime creator.

Danielle Kirsty

Straightforward but engaging, Danielle Kirsty’s videos are packed with research and passion for storytelling. Her calm demeanour and clear love of the subject make her videos binge-worthy. She also has a way of sharing the victims’ stories with the utmost care and respect, which is so important in true crime.

Swoop

Swoop is not your average true crime YouTuber. Her personality shines in every video, with powerful storytelling and a unique approach that captures both the shock and humanity of these cases. Her content stands out because of her ability to pivot between entertaining narratives and meaningful conversations about societal issues.

Bella Fiori

Bella brings a slightly vlog-style twist to true crime. Her relatable personality makes you feel like you’re sitting down with a friend who just happens to know everything about crime stories. She’s incredibly approachable, making even complex cases easy to follow and engrossing for viewers.

Sherrilyn Dale

For those who like quieter, more reflective storytelling, Sherrilyn Dale is perfection. Her well-thought-out videos carry an almost meditative quality, putting the focus firmly on the victims and their stories. She is definitely one of my favourites!

Kimbyrleigha

Kimbyrleigha is your go-to if you’re intrigued by psychological crimes and relationship dynamics. She covers tragic stories with the sensitivity they deserve while connecting behavioural patterns to larger societal issues. Her background in psychology comes shining through in every case.

Annie Elise (10 to Life)

If you love fresh takes on cases, you won’t want to miss Annie Elise. Her channel, 10 to Life, offers thorough case analyses and a focus on less-covered crimes. Annie’s approachable tone makes even the darkest of cases feel digestible.

Rachel Shannon True Crime

Rachel Shannon’s channel is filled with compelling cases, told with a relatable, easygoing hosting style that makes her videos addictive. Her seamless blend of research and empathy will have you hooked from the start.

Danelle Hallan

Danelle Hallan is another thoughtful creator who is an absolute gem in the true crime world. She goes the extra mile to tell the untold stories of victims, often shedding light on forgotten or lesser-known cases. Her commitment to ethical storytelling deserves all the recognition. Danelle also covers a lot of child exploitation and missing unsolved cases which I always enjoy.

Darklivity

Darklivity is one for true crime fans who enjoy exploring the darker side of human behaviour. This channel dives into cases with haunting details, paired with sharp analysis. What I love most? Their ability to make even the most horrifying details feel approachable without trivialising the subject matter.

True Crime Podcasts Worth Every Second

I Could Murder a Podcast

For fans of dark humour and witty banter, I Could Murder a Podcast is pure gold. Hosts Tom and Ben dissect cases with a balance of research, storytelling, and British charm. It’s like having your most entertaining friends walk you through the darkest corners of history.

Why These Creators Have My Heart

What makes these YouTubers and podcasters so special isn’t just the cases they cover but how they cover them. Whether it’s Bailey Sarian’s vibrant storytelling, Emma Kenny’s deep dives, or Danielle Kirsty’s respectful tone, each creator brings a unique perspective to the table.

Their dedication to the craft is what makes the world of true crime so engaging. They remind us that behind every harrowing tale exists a cautionary lesson and, above all, real people.

Start Following the Best

True crime fans like us know there’s no shortage of new stories, twists, and revelations to uncover. Whether it’s a chilling unsolved mystery or a deep exploration of criminal psychology, these creators are absolute pros at entertaining, informing, and even teaching us.

Watch, listen, immerse yourself, and maybe even guess the whodunnits before they do! Got any favourites I didn’t list? Drop them in the comments. Now, go grab your headphones or settle into your couch – your next crime binge awaits.

If you found this helpful please share!